| Date
| Match
| MOTM (% of votes)
|
| 25/04/09 |
BSP v Rushden & Diamonds (A) |
Paul Lorraine (37%) |
| 18/04/09 |
BSP v Mansfield Town (H) |
Paul Lorraine (41%) |
| 13/04/09 |
BSP v Oxford United (H) |
Paul Lorraine (21%) |
| 11/04/09 |
BSP v Forest Green Rovers (A) |
Micah Hyde (34%) |
| 07/04/09 |
BSP v Northwich Victoria (A) |
Wilfried Domoraud (67%) |
| 04/04/09 |
BSP v Barrow (A) |
Danny Knowles (38%) |
| 01/04/09 |
BSP v Kidderminster Harriers (H) |
Danny Knowles (22%) |
| 30/03/09 |
BSP v Cambridge United (H) |
Matt Pattison (39%) |
| 21/03/09 |
BSP v Kidderminster Harriers (A) |
Danny Knowles (33%) |
| 14/03/09 |
BSP v Wrexham (H) |
Danny Knowles (30%) |
| 07/03/09 |
BSP v Barrow (H) |
Rob Elvins (50%) |
| 28/02/09 |
BSP v Burton Albion (H) |
Paul Lorraine (26%) |
| 24/02/09 |
BSP v Stevenage Borough (A) |
Oliver Bozanic (26%) |
| 21/02/09 |
BSP v Altrincham (A) |
Paul Lorraine (31%) |
| 17/02/09 |
BSP v Salisbury City (A) |
Rob Elvins (21%) |
| 14/02/09 |
BSP v Kettering Town (H) |
Oliver Bozanic (47%) |
| 31/01/09 |
BSP v Northwich Victoria (H) |
Wilfried Domoraud (57%) |
| 27/01/09 |
BSP v Eastbourne Borough (H) |
Wilfried Domoraud (69%) |
| 24/01/09 |
BSP v Ebbsfleet United (H) |
Oliver Bozanic (49%) |
| 20/01/09 |
SSC v Leatherhead (H) |
Charlie Moone (24%) |
| 17/01/09 |
BSP v Cambridge United (A) |
Simon Eastwood (60%) |
| 13/01/09 |
SS v Forest Green Rovers (H) |
Simon Eastwood (27%) |
| 01/01/09 |
BSP v Crawley Town (A) |
Matt Pattison (32%) |
| 28/12/08 |
BSP v Wrexham (A) |
No Vote |
| 26/12/08 |
BSP v Crawley Town (H) |
Matt Pattison (40%) |
| 20/12/08 |
BSP v Lewes (A) |
Wilfried Domoraud (63%) |
| 16/12/08 |
FAT v Salisbury City (H) |
Liam Marum (58%) |
| 09/12/08 |
BSP v Rushden & Diamonds (H) |
Matt Pattison (34%) |
| 06/12/08 |
BSP v Histon (A) |
Paul Lorraine (45%) |
| 02/12/08 |
SS v Salisbury City (A) |
Nick Gindre (34%) |
| 26/11/08 |
SSC v Croydon (A) |
Charlie Moone (33%) |
| 22/11/08 |
v Torquay United (H) |
Nick Gindre (43%) |
| 18/11/08 |
v Weymouth (A) |
Paul Lorraine (50%) |
| 15/11/08 |
v Eastbourne Borough (A) |
Lenny Pidgeley (33%) |
| 08/11/08 |
SS v Bognor Regis Town (H) |
Charlie Moone (33%) |
| 01/11/08 |
v Stevenage Borough (H) |
Lenny Pidgeley (70%) |
| 28/10/08 |
FAC Replay v Ebbsfleet United (A) |
Paul Lorraine (34%) |
| 25/10/08 |
FAC v Ebbsfleet United (H) |
Paul Lorraine (41%) |
| 18/10/08 |
v Grays Athletic (A) |
Paul Lorraine (74%) |
| 11/10/08 |
v York City (H) |
Goma Lambu (66%) |
| 07/10/08 |
v Weymouth (H) |
Paul Lorraine (41%) |
| 04/10/08 |
v Mansfield Town (A) |
Paul Lorraine and
Tom Hutchinson (22%) |
| 27/09/08 |
v Histon (H) |
Wilfried Domoraud (27%) |
| 23/09/08 |
v Salisbury City (H) |
Liam Marum (20%) |
| 20/09/08 |
v Ebbsfleet United (A) |
Liam Marum (36%) |
| 13/09/08 |
v Grays Athletic (H) |
Goma Lambu (25%) |
| 06/09/08 |
v York City (A) |
Goma Lambu (48%) |
| 02/09/08 |
v Lewes (H) |
Wilfried Domoraud (28%) |
| 30/08/08 |
v Kettering Town (A) |
Tom Hutchinson (33%) |
| 25/08/08 |
v Oxford United (A) |
Paul Lorraine (53%) |
| 23/08/08 |
v Forest Green Rovers (H) |
Lenny Pidgeley (53%) |
| 16/08/08 |
v Burton Albion (A) |
Giuseppe Sole (31%) |
| 12/08/08 |
v Torquay United (A) |
Ross Worner (38%) |
| 09/08/08 |
v Altrincham (H) |
Delano Sam-Yorke (41%) |
